hey scott.
I would like to help you solve your workflow problem.
I work on a news channel where we have to deliver very fast and rely on fast psd/ai->ae workflow
making the shift from psd vectors to ae is kind of my expertise.
I also teach students where troubleshooting psd/ai->ae is my main teaching focus.
but enough about me, please contact if you still need some help and me I am pretty sure I can help you sort some of this mess out.