that's right Danny it is messy but I figured out the workflow. its just this duration / frame rate thing that would will make it better.
the first dialog box is basically for multiple files -> you can select many files and for them choose footage/Layer size/Comp Size
and you won't get another dialog box after that. but, alas, Â its with merged layer styles and merged masks (if it's Photoshop of course)
if you choose only one file in the first dialog box and choose there Layer size/Comp Size -you will get another dialog box with the selection you did before,Â
giving you the option to merge layer styles and masks or not.
if you choose only one file in the first dialog box and choose there Footage - it will ignore your selection in the next dialog box and you have to select footage again from there.
so basically you should ignore the first dialog box altogether (unless you want multiple files with merged layer styles merged masks).
Â